|Year : 2019 | Volume
| Issue : 1 | Page : 7-11
|Antimicrobial efficacy of liquorice against Enterococcus faecalis biofilms in various concentrations at time-dependent variables: An in vitro study
M Chittrarasu1, Srinivasan Sai Sathyanarayana2, Shafie Ahamed2, Arularasi Aberna3, S Bhavani2, G Rajaraman2
1 Department of Conservative Dentistry and Endodontics, Vivekanandha Dental College for Women, Tiruchengode, Namakkal, India
2 Department of Conservative Dentistry and Endodontics, Faculty of Dentistry, Rajah Muthiah Dental College and Hospital, Annamalai Nagar, Tamil Nadu, India
3 Department of Microbiology, Faculty of Dentistry, Rajah Muthiah Dental College and Hospital, Annamalai Nagar, Tamil Nadu, India
Click here for correspondence address and email
|Date of Submission||26-May-2018|
|Date of Decision||15-Aug-2018|
|Date of Acceptance||07-Sep-2018|
|Date of Web Publication||14-Feb-2019|
| Abstract|| |
Introduction: The purpose this study was to evaluate the inhibitory efficacy of liquorice at various concentrations against Enterococcus faecalis and their biofilms at time-dependent variables in 24 h, 48 h, 72 h, 120 h, and 168 h.
Materials and Methods: The antienterococcal activity of liquorice and calcium hydroxide was detected employing concentration ranging from 1–4 g and interpreted based on the zone of inhibition. The ability of liquorice to inhibit E. faecalis biofilms during the stages of growth kinetics on microtiter plate was assessed, and the biofilm architecture was evaluated by scanning electron microscope (SEM).
Results: Statistically significant antienterococcal was observed at 3 and 4 g of liquorice against 24 and 48 h on microtiter plates. This observation was also complimented by SEM studies of biofilm architecture cultivated in root canals.
Conclusions: E. faecalis biofilms at 24 h and 48 h were highly susceptible to liquorice at concentration of 3 and 4 g.
Keywords: Antimicrobial efficacy; biofilms; calcium hydroxide; Enterococcus faecalis; liquorice
|How to cite this article:|
Chittrarasu M, Sathyanarayana SS, Ahamed S, Aberna A, Bhavani S, Rajaraman G. Antimicrobial efficacy of liquorice against Enterococcus faecalis biofilms in various concentrations at time-dependent variables: An in vitro study. J Conserv Dent 2019;22:7-11
|How to cite this URL:|
Chittrarasu M, Sathyanarayana SS, Ahamed S, Aberna A, Bhavani S, Rajaraman G. Antimicrobial efficacy of liquorice against Enterococcus faecalis biofilms in various concentrations at time-dependent variables: An in vitro study. J Conserv Dent [serial online] 2019 [cited 2019 Nov 21];22:7-11. Available from: http://www.jcd.org.in/text.asp?2019/22/1/7/252239
| Introduction|| |
Enterococcus faecalis is associated with root canal treatment failures owing to their ability of growth in nutrition limited and harsh environmental conditions. Biofilms established by E. faecalis in association with other pathogenic bacteria complicate the problem manifold. A successful endodontic treatment requires complete elimination or reduction of E. faecalis or their biofilms from anatomically complex root canal architecture. Various traditional herbs and chemical compounds have been evaluated for their inhibitory spectrum against root canal flora. In ancient literature, liquorice has been reported to present antimicrobial flavoring preparation. This study evaluates the activity of liquorice on both E. faecalis culture and its biofilms at various stages of growth kinetics to explore its possibility as root canal medicament.
| Materials and Methods|| |
Enterococcus faecalisstrain and chemicals used for the study
E. faecalis strain (RC115) was isolated from the root canal of a patient exhibiting repeated root canal treated failure. The isolate was identified and speciated based on conventional methods and polymerase chain reaction.
A dry liquorice extract (Sami labs Pvt. Ltd.,) employed for the study was obtained in a solid state which appears light yellow-to-brown powder. Calcium hydroxide (prime dent) was chosen as a control compound.
Efficacy of liquorice on Enterococcus faecalis culture
Screening for the active concentration of liquorice by disk-diffusion assay
Sterile paper discs were separately impregnated with liquorice and calcium hydroxide each at concentration of 1, 2, 3, and 4 g/ml and air dried aseptically. Overnight, broth cultures of E. faecalis RC115 on the brain–heart infusion broth (HiMedia) were adjusted to 0.5 McFarland standards and used as inoculum. A lawn culture of the inoculum was made on the dry surface of Mueller–Hinton agar plate (HiMedia). Liquorice and calcium hydroxide discs at various concentrations were placed on inoculated media at a distance of 2 cm. The plates were incubated overnight in a capnophilic environment, and following incubation, then the plates were observed for the zone of inhibition around the medicated paper discs.
Testing the antibiofilm activity of liquorice and calcium hydroxide
Preparation of biofilms
The ability of liquorice and calcium hydroxide to inhibit the biofilms E. faecalis was assayed on microtiter plate as per the protocol of Toledo Arana et al. (2001).
Testing the antibiofilm activity of liquorice and calcium hydroxide by viable count method
Biofilms of E. faecalis RC115 formed on microtiter plate on the days 1, 2, 3, 5, and 7 were treated individually with 3 and 4 g/ml of liquorice and calcium hydroxide. Wells without medicament were used as control. The biofilm containing microtiter plate was inoculated in a capnophilic environment for overnight. Following incubation, the microtiter plates were taken, and the viable count of E. faecalis from each of the liquorice and calcium hydroxide treated test wells and control wells was done.
Viable count method
The test and control wells were washed with 20 μl of phosphate-buffered saline twice. The cells in biofilms were obtained with 20 μl of phosphate-buffered saline and transferred to sterile 1.5 ml microcentrifuge tube. Ten-fold serial dilutions of the bacterial suspension from each well made and 10 μl of each dilution was plated as a lawn culture on nutrient agar using sterile spreader. The plates were incubated in capnophilic environment overnight. The cfu/ml of each dilution was calculated to determine the viable number of E. faecalis.
Testing the antibiofilm activity of liquorice and calcium hydroxide by optical density measurements (A495)
Biofilms of E. faecalis RC115 formed on microtiter plate on the days 1, 2, 3, 5, and 7 were observed for the inhibitory activity of liquorice and calcium hydroxide at concentration of 3 and 4 g/ml. Following incubation of biofilms with the medicament, the wells were stained and destained, and the optical density of the destaining solution was measured at A495 using microtiter plate reader (Toledo Arana et al., 2001). The test was done in duplicate. Uninoculated medium was used as control. The mean A495 value from the control wells was subtracted from the mean A495 value of test wells.
Cultivation of Biofilms on root canals
The ability of liquorice to inhibit E. faecalis biofilms formed on anatomically complex site in the root canal was determined by culturing biofilms on extracted premolars.
Testing of medicament (liquorice and calcium hydroxide) on Enterococcus faecalis lms in root canal by scanning electron microscope
Freshly extracted 15 single-rooted premolars with mature apices were selected and stored in hydrogen peroxide. The crowns were removed using standardized endodontic protocol. The tooth length was standardized to 18 mm from the root apex to the coronal border. Cleaning and shaping of samples were performed using Flexer Heat Activation rotary nickel–titanium system (Mothers Dental Products Pvt. Ltd., Ireland) as per the protocol of Shehab El-Din (2012). Then, tooth was wrapped with aluminium foil. The teeth were then air dried and autoclaved. All samples were mounted individually in wax block and sealed. Pure culture suspension of E. faecalis RC115 grown overnight in brain–heart infusion broth and adjusted McFarland turbidity standard was used as inoculum, and fill the root canals of the teeth were sealed and incubated as earlier. Suitable positive and negative control were included as stated earlier.
Addition of Medicaments on biofilms in root canal
Biofilms on the days 1, 2, and 3 were taken and treated with liquorice and calcium hydroxide each at concentrations of 3 and 4 g/ml. Following addition of medications, the tooth was incubated as earlier and prepared for scanning electron microscopic analysis.
Scanning electron microscope analysis of medicated biofilm in root canals
All teeth were washed with PBS after 24 h, 48 h, and 72 h, respectively, and the samples were cut into longitudinal sections with safe-sided diamond disc mounted on a high-speed contra-angle with water coolant. Each sample was mounted and gold sputter was coated (JFC 1600 auto fine coater) with a 200 Š layer of gold-palladium. Observation was performed using a JEOL JSM-5610LV scanning electron microscope (SEM) at 15 kV.
| Results|| |
The results were tabulated and statistically analyzed using paired samples statistics [Table 1].
|Table 1: Comparison of the mean values of liquorice and calcium hydroxide against biofilms of Enterococcus faecalis at varying time intervals between groups (paired samples statistics)|
Click here to view
- Screening for the antienterococcal activity of liquorice and calcium hydroxide
Results of disk-diffusion employing concentration range of medicaments from 1 to 4 g show zone of inhibition of 13 and 14 mm for liquorice and for calcium hydroxide at 3 and 4 g, respectively
- Antibiofilm activity of medicaments on microtiter plates
The OD values of A595 for biofilms tested with liquorice showed <0.4 at 24 h, and at 168 h ranged from 1.4 to 1.6, the OD values at A495 on calcium hydroxide treated biofilms showed higher values >0.4 at 24 h and >1.5 at 168 h. The highest OD values were found at 72 h with a range of 1.5–1.6 for liquorice treated biofilm of 1.7–1.9 for calcium hydroxide treated biofilm [Chart 1] and [Chart 2]
- In an effort to mimic the activity of liquorice in an anatomical complex site, enterococcal biofilms were cultivated in extracted premolar root canals. The ability of liquorice in inhibiting the 24 and 48-h-old biofilms was well evident in observing the reduction in biofilm architecture through SEM studies [Figure 1] and [Figure 2].
|Figure 1: Inhibition of Enterococcus faecalis biofilms by medicament at concentration of 4 g. L: Liquorice, C: Calciumhydroxide|
Click here to view
|Figure 2: Inhibition of Enterococcus faecalis biofilms by medicament at concentration of 3 g. L: Liquorice, C: Calcium hydroxide|
Click here to view
| Discussion|| |
Enterococcus species live as commensals in the human intestinal lumen, human female genital tract, and the oral cavity. The prevalence of E. faecalis is increased in oral rinse samples from patients receiving initial endodontic treatment, those midway through treatment, and patients receiving endodontic retreatment when compared to those with no endodontic history. Therefore, it is important to consider treatment regimens aimed at eliminating or preventing the infection of E. faecalis during each of these phases.
Preparing the apical portion of the root canal to a larger instrument size will help eliminate intracanal microorganisms by reaching areas which are inaccessible by smaller master apical files. In addition, larger apical preparation sizes facilitate removal of the innermost (pulpal) dentin. This provides the potential to remove intratubular bacteria and open the dentinal tubules to allow antimicrobials to penetrate more effectively.
Biomechanical cleaning and shaping of the root canal with the assistance of antimicrobial irrigants may fail to eliminate bacteria from the root canal. Residual bacteria in the dentinal tubules may multiply which negatively affects the repair of periradicular apparatus. The use of a biocompatible intracanal medication possessing antimicrobial properties between appointments may reduce or eliminate bacteria in the root canal system and also significantly increase the success of root canal therapy.
According to Gurib–fakim, there are four basic ways in which plants that are used by tribal peoples are valuable in modern medicine.
- Plants used as sources of direct therapeutic agents
- Plants are also used as sources of starting points for the elaboration of semisynthetic compounds
- Plants can serve as sources of substances that can be used as models for new synthetic compounds
- Plants can also be used as taxonomic markers for the discovery of new compounds.
The extract of dried liquorice root powder was used in the present study. The roots main component is glycyrrhizin, a triterpene molecule which accounts for the sweet taste of liquorice root. This compound represents a mixture of potassium-calcium-magnesium salts of glycyrrhizinic acid that varies within a range of 2%–25%. Chromatographic analysis of the root reveals a wide variety of components such as flavonoids, isoflavonoids, coumarins, saponins, glycosides, and phenols. Among the natural saponins, glycyrrhizinic acid is a molecule composed of a hydrophilic part, two molecules of glucuronic acid and a hydrophobic component, glycyrrhetic acid.
In this study, the zone of inhibition was calculated in various concentrations such as 4 g, 3 g, 2 g, and 1 g of liquorice and calcium hydroxide against E. faecalis. The results of the study showed that after overnight incubation, the concentration of 4 g and 3 g of liquorice showed the highest zone of inhibition in plates than calcium hydroxide. This finding is in agreement with a study carried out by Badr et al. where the antimicrobial efficacy of liquorice and calcium hydroxide was compared against E. faecalis, and it was concluded that liquorice extract had significant antimicrobial activity against these organisms.
Shalhav et al. proposed that the process of evaluating antienterococcal properties of dental materials more than one assay or method should be used. For this reason, the broth dilution test on microtiter plates was also performed to evaluate the extent of antimicrobial activity and to measure the minimum inhibitory concentration of liquorice extract and calcium hydroxide. The agar diffusion test gave a qualitative value of bacterial sensitivity, and the broth dilution test gave quantitative results. The intracanal medication used ideally should reach the microorganisms located in the distant areas of the root canal system and should remain for a longer duration of time.
The biofilm results of this study revealed that liquorice extract and Ca(OH)2 mixture were killed effective against E. faecalis, while liquorice alone had only a marginal antimicrobial effect. The weak antibacterial effect of Ca(OH)2 against E. faecalis in this study is in agreement with studies done by Safavi et al. 1990 and Peters et al. 2002. According to Badria et al., the antimicrobial effect of liquorice extract against E. faecalis may be related to the glycyrrhizin. The mode of action of antibacterial effects of saponin seems to involve membranolytic properties, rather than simply altering the surface tension of the extracellular medium, thus being influenced by microbial population density. The flavonoid content of liquorice extract is also a strong inhibitor of oxygen consumption in bacterial cells; the site of inhibition is thought to be between coenzyme Q and cytochrome C in the bacterial respiratory electron transport chain.
Biofilms at growth kinetics of 24 and 48 h, when treated with liquorice, demonstrated a reduction in CFU/ml of enterococci as tested by viable count assay and the paucity of biofilm architecture by SEM studies compared to the negative group.
Saber Sel-D, El-Hady et al. in their study assessed the mature biofilm of E. faecalis against various antimicrobial agents such as calcium hydroxide, amoxicillin, and clavulanate potassium, ciprofloxacin, clindamycin, and doxycline. He concluded that these agents were significantly better than calcium hydroxide, whereas in the present study, there is a reduction in biofilm forming ability of E. faecalis in the presence of liquorice at a concentration of 4 and 3 g and 24 and 48-h-old biofilm than calcium hydroxide, thus supporting the observations of the previous study.
A systematic review by Sathorn et al. on the antibacterial effect of Ca(OH)2 as an intracanal medicament showed limited disinfection activity within the root canal system. In a recent systematic review published by Saatchi et al., they report no improvement in antibacterial activity by mixing chlorhexidine and Ca(OH)2.
| Conclusions|| |
Based on the results of the present study, it can be concluded that as follows:
- Liquorice extract revealed higher activity than calcium hydroxide against enterococci by disk-diffusion method at a concentration of 3 and 4 g
- Liquorice exhibited on better activity (P < 0.05) on biofilms formed on microtiter plates with statistically significant reduction in cfu/ml (0.298) and A495 (0.298)
- In an effect to mimic the activity of liquorice in an anatomical complex site, enterococcal biofilms were cultivated in extracted premolar root canals. The ability of liquorice in inhibiting the 24 and 48-h-old biofilms was well evident in observing the reduction in biofilm architecture through SEM studies.
Based on the single species model used, this study shows that liquorice extract can be used as an intracanal irrigant and root canal medicament. Liquorice has been used for the treatment of many general body ailments such as eye diseases, throat infections, peptic ulcers, and liver diseases in the Indian Ayurvedic system. It has been proved to be a more biocompatible material. Further clinical trials are essential to prove liquorice as an alternative intracanal medicament.
Financial support and sponsorship
Conflicts of interest
There are no conflicts of interest.
| References|| |
Stuart CH, Schwartz SA, Beeson TJ, Owatz CB. Enterococcus faecalis
: Its role in root canal treatment failure and current concepts in retreatment. J Endod 2006;32:93-8.
Barnett F, Trope M, Khoja M, Tronstad L. Bacteriologic status of the root canal after sonic, ultrasonic and hand instrumentation. Endod Dent Traumatol 1985;1:228-31.
Fukai T, Marumo A, Kaitou K, Kanda T, Terada S, Nomura T, et al.
Anti-helicobacter pylori flavonoids from licorice extract. Life Sci 2002;71:1449-63.
Koch S, Hufnagel M, Theilacker C, Huebner J. Enterococcal infections: Host response, therapeutic, and prophylactic possibilities. Vaccine 2004;22:822-30.
Card SJ, Sigurdsson A, Orstavik D, Trope M. The effectiveness of increased apical enlargement in reducing intracanal bacteria. J Endod 2002;28:779-83.
Siqueira JF Jr. Machado AG, Silveira RM, Lopes HP, de Uzeda M. Evaluation of the effectiveness of sodium hypochlorite used with three irrigation methods in the elimination of Enterococcus faecalis
from the root canal, in vitro
. Int Endod J 1997;30:279-82.
Lynne RE, Liewehr FR, West LA, Patton WR, Buxton TB, McPherson JC, et al. In vitro
antimicrobial activity of various medication preparations on E. Faecalis
in root canal dentin. J Endod 2003;29:187-90.
Shanbhog R, Nandlal B, Mohit B. Efficacy of 5% w/v sustained-release metronidazole gel preparation against Enterococcus faecalis
in necrotic tooth - Randomized clinical trail. Int J Curr Sci Technol 2015;3:53-8.
Attia DA, Farag AM, Afifi IK, Darrag AM. Antimicrobial effect of different intracanal medications on various microorganisms. Tanta Dent J 2015;12:41-7.
Gurib-Fakim A. Medicinal plants: Traditions of yesterday and drugs of tomorrow. Mol Aspects Med 2006;27:1-93.
Kataria R, Singh HG, Gupta A, Jalhan S, Jindal A. Pharmacological activities on Glycyrrhiza glabra
– A review. Asian J Pharm Clin Res 2013:6 supple 1;5-7.
Badr AE, Omar N, Badria FA. A laboratory evaluation of the antibacterial and cytotoxic effect of liquorice when used as root canal medicament. Int Endod J 2011;44:51-8.
Shalhav M, Fuss Z, Weiss EI.In vitro
antibacterial activity of a glassionomer endodontic sealer. J Endod 1997;23:616-9.
Safavi KE, Spangberg LS, Langeland K. Root canal dentinal tubule disinfection. J Endod 1990;16:207-10.
Peters LB, van Winkelhoff AJ, Buijs JF, Wesselink PR. Effects of instrumentation, irrigation and dressing with calcium hydroxide on infection in pulpless teeth with periapical bone lesions. Int Endod J 2002;35:13-21.
Killeen G, Madigan C, Connolly C, Walsh G, Clark C, Hynes M, et al.
Antimicrobial saponins of Yucca schidigera
and the implicationsof their in vitro
properties for their in vivo
impact. J Agric Food Chem 1998;46:3178-86.
Haraguchi H, Tanimoto K, Tamura Y, Mizutani K, Kinoshita T. Mode of antibacterial action of retrochalcones from Glycyrrhiza inflata
. Phytochemistry 1998;48:125-9.
Saber Sel-D, El-Hady SA. Development of an intracanal mature Enterococcus faecalis
biofilm and its susceptibility to some antimicrobial intracanal medications; An in vitro
study. Eur J Dent 2012;6:43-50.
Sathorn C, Parashos P, Messer H. Antibacterial efficacy of calcium hydroxide intracanal dressing: A systematic review and meta-analysis. Int Endod J 2007;40:2-10.
Saatchi M, Shokraneh A, Navaei H, Maracy MR, Shojaei H. Antibacterial effect of calcium hydroxide combined with chlorhexidine on Enterococcus faecalis
: A systematic review and meta-analysis. J Appl Oral Sci 2014;22:356-65.
Dr. M Chittrarasu
Department of Conservative Dentistry and Endodontics, Vivekanandha Dental College for Women, Elayampalayam, Tiruchengode, Namakkal - 637 205, Tamil Nadu
Source of Support: None, Conflict of Interest: None
[Figure 1], [Figure 2]
| Article Access Statistics|
| Viewed||975 |
| Printed||12 |
| Emailed||0 |
| PDF Downloaded||217 |
| Comments ||[Add] |